SaaS Competitor Analysis: How to Cut through the Clutter

Shiyam Sunder
|
August 29, 2024
SaaS Competitor Analysis: How to Cut through the Clutter

Contents

Key Takeaways

The SaaS industry is cut-throat. We have over 30,000 tools and collaboration applications in the market today. Imagine facing nearly 17,000 competitors in customer service solutions, 15,000 in marketing software, and many more in other segments. Even with an outstanding product, making a mark in this crowded market requires exceptional effort and strategy.  

For startups and established SaaS companies alike, thorough SaaS competitor analysis is essential for understanding your market, positioning your product, and developing effective strategies. Take for example this comparison page on Atlassian's website -

Certainly, this messaging strategy results from a thorough study of their direct competitor's pricing strategy and feature comparison. They likely gathered insights from customer feedback on platforms like G2 or Trustpilot, observed discussions in social media forums and online communities such as Reddit and Discord, and employed competitive intelligence tools to collect and interpret competitor data.

All of these are great ways to conduct comprehensive SaaS competitor analysis, an integral part of market research and business strategy. 

Customer reviews of Asana on G2

Are you looking to create a strategy that sets you apart from your competitors? Here's a comprehensive guide to conducting a competitive analysis for your SaaS business.

What is SaaS Competitive Analysis?

SaaS competitive analysis is the process of identifying, evaluating, and understanding the strengths and weaknesses of competitors within the SaaS market. This analysis helps businesses compare their products, features, pricing, marketing strategies, and customer experiences against those of their rivals.

A strategic approach to SaaS competitive analysis is a thorough examination of your company's position relative to others in the industry. For instance, a SaaS company in the project management software space might need to assess how its features and pricing compare to established competitors like Asana or Trello. Using this information, businesses can make strategic decisions that enable them to differentiate their offerings, identify opportunities for improvement, and ultimately gain a competitive edge in the market.

Benefits of SaaS Competitor Analysis

Competitor analysis is the cornerstone of a successful go-to-market (GTM) strategy. A Harvard Business School study revealed that 95% of the 30,000 products launched annually fail. This is largely due to common pitfalls like incorrect product assumptions and inadequate long-term planning.

By understanding your competitors' strengths, weaknesses, and market positioning, you can avoid these errors and create an effective GTM strategy 

Understand Your Market and Customers

By analyzing your competitors, you can gain a deeper understanding of your market and customers. This allows you to identify your product’s unique strengths, uncover unmet needs, and align your product development and marketing efforts with customer preferences. Additionally, comparing your performance to industry benchmarks helps you set realistic goals and measure your progress effectively.

Making Informed Strategic Business Decisions

Say you’re doing your market research and notice that most solutions are priced significantly high because customers frequently mention it in reviews. 

Knowing this, you set competitive prices to draw customers in. This becomes your product positioning strategy–highlighted through your website, marketing materials, and even sales efforts.

That’s just one example of how competitor analysis can help make strategic business decisions. Analyzing competitor marketing efforts can help identify the channels where your customers are more active, the messaging that resonates with them, or their perceived problems. By tracking competitor product roadmaps and updates, you can prioritize feature enhancements and product improvements that give you a competitive edge.

Bolstering Investor Confidence

A thorough competitive analysis helps demonstrate your in-depth knowledge of the market, industry trends, and competitor dynamics. It helps you position yourself as an informed entrepreneur.

Highlighting your ability to identify market opportunities and navigate competitive pressures can build trust with investors. It demonstrates your ability to create a clear roadmap and show the potential of your SaaS venture.

Laying the foundation for SaaS competitor analysis

A frequent mistake startups make is projecting their assumptions onto their target audience. When developing a product with AI capabilities, entrepreneurs might assume that this feature is the main selling point. 

However, customer insights might reveal - that 'strong integrations' are what customers value most— something competitors might be missing. To bridge this gap, it's essential to delve into the often-overlooked sources of information that form the foundation of your SaaS competitive analysis:

1.Analyzing competitor websites and social media

For SaaS businesses, a website is the primary pillar for the business.The good news is, that you can use the website to collect most of the information needed for competitor analysis as well. Whether it is analyzing their positioning, what features they choose to highlight (value proposition), and how they choose to convey this on their website (messaging) and pricing tiers.

Tip: An underestimated source is the knowledge base found on most of the websites. Although many SaaS products have steep learning curves, businesses often fail to provide adequate help in terms of help articles and knowledge base. Make sure to analyze if your competitors have made this crucial mistake. 

Apart from the website, social media is a great tool to understand the tone, and voice of the brand. It also helps you figure out how the brand interacts with the audience, and engage with their current and potential customers. Studying these channels should be the first step in SaaS competitive analysis. 

2.Scrutinizing customer review sites

Another great source of information is customer reviews on platforms like G2, Capterra, and Trustpilot. They reveal how customers perceive your competitors' products. 

Assessing negative feedback isn’t sufficient, look for reviews that highlight problematic features or requested additions. Check if these problems have been addressed in new feature updates. If not, it might indicate customer dissatisfaction.

By assessing this feedback, you can understand what might influence customers to switch from competitors to your product. This insight can help you develop strategies to overcome switching barriers and attract new customers.

3.Conducting customer calls and interviews

Conduct one-on-one interviews or calls with your competitors’s customers to gain a deeper understanding of their experiences and needs. Ask questions about their decision-making process, including - 

  • What problems are you currently facing?
  • Why did you choose your current solution?
  • What would make you consider switching?
  • Which features do you value most?
  • Have you encountered any frustrations?

Another great way to gather this information is during demo calls. Look for the specific features that draw a positive reaction. This can help pinpoint benefits or market segments that your competitors might be missing. 

4.Examining sales enablement documents

Analyze your sales enablement materials, such as sales decks and product sheets, to identify the key features and benefits they emphasize. This helps strengthen marketing-sales alignment and meet business objectives.

For example, Gorgias, a popular help desk software, initially positioned itself as the opposite of AI chatbots, promising genuine human interactions. However, the rising popularity of AI and the subsequent emphasis on AI by its competitors like Zendesk quickly made them pivot their messaging.  

Conducting SaaS competitive analysis: A step-by-step guide

With a solid foundation in place, let's explore a step-by-step guide on how to leverage the data and insights you've gathered to conduct a comprehensive competitive analysis.

Step 1: Identify Direct Competitors

To begin your SaaS competitive analysis, conduct a thorough online examination using search engines and specialized SaaS review platforms. Identify top-performing solutions within your niche to identify the direct competition, but don't stop there. Categorize direct and indirect competitors that might emerge in your market. 

Taking a project management software company and determining its competitors: 

  • Direct Competitors: These brands offer a product or service identical to yours, targeting the same audience. Customers will likely compare your offerings when making a purchase decision. For example, Asana and Monday.com are direct competitors. 
  • Indirect Competitors: These businesses address the same core problem but through different solutions. They might present opportunities to expand your product's reach and functionality. For instance, Slack and Google Workspace employ different approaches for productivity and project management.
  • Legacy Competitors: These are established companies with a long-standing presence in your industry. They often possess a solid reputation and customer trust. Zoho and Jira are legacy competitors in the project management space.
  • Emerging Competitors: New players with innovative business models and unique value propositions can pose a significant threat to existing brands. Consider Clickup and Trello, which disrupted the project management space by surpassing the performance of several established competitors.

Step 2: Analyze Competitor Strategies

To analyze competitor marketing strategies, delve into their marketing channels. Examine their website structure, copy, content marketing strategy, and brand voice to understand their positioning. 

Subscribe to their newsletters to learn about their messaging cadence, writing style, and content focus. Use tools like Ahrefs and Semrush to identify if they are running paid ads on search engines.

Explore their thought leadership efforts, such as podcasts, webinars, and courses. Analyze their digital PR strategy to see if they are building buzz through media coverage. Evaluate their social media presence, including the channels they use and the type of content that resonates with their audience.

Finally, assess their partnerships to understand if they are collaborating with other companies for mutual benefit. By conducting a thorough competitive analysis of these marketing channels, you can create a detailed document that furnishes valuable insights into your competitors' strategies.

Step 3: Gather Customer Insights

As mentioned above, monitoring how competitors engage with customers on social media platforms and analyzing customer reviews on external platforms helps a lot. This will provide valuable insights into customer sentiment, expectations, and pain points.

Step 4: Compare and Evaluate Gaps

Use a structured framework (covered in the next section) to compare your performance against competitors, assessing factors like product features, pricing, marketing effectiveness, and customer satisfaction. Identify gaps in competitors' messaging and carve out a niche for yourself.

Founders and marketers in early-stage SaaS companies often overlook the immense power of differentiation. As a newer company, standing out in a crowded market is crucial to attracting customers and securing funding. 

Consider Scheduler AI, a promising startup in the scheduling software space dominated by giants like Calendly and Chili Piper.

To differentiate themselves, Scheduler AI created a 'Problem Section' on their homepage. Instead of simply claiming to be a scheduling tool, they highlighted the specific pain points that other solutions often fail to address. By acknowledging the limitations of existing tools, they positioned themselves as the solution that could truly handle the entire end-to-end scheduling process.

Differentiator on Scheduler.ai's home page

Utilizing SaaS competitive analysis through the framework

Frameworks provide a structured approach to competitive analysis, enhancing focus, clarity, and the ability to make comparisons. By utilizing established models like SWOT analysis, Porter's Five Forces, and perceptual mapping, you can gain valuable insights into your market and identify growth opportunities.

1. SWOT Analysis

SWOT analysis is a powerful tool for evaluating your strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. By identifying your unique selling points and areas where you may need to improve, you can develop strategies to differentiate your SaaS product and address potential challenges.

Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats
  • Seamless integrations
  • Advanced task automation
  • Intuitive user interfaces
  • Lack of customization options
  • integration challenges with certain platforms
  • Higher cost
  • Growing adoption of remote work
  • Increasing demand for collaborative features
  • Advancements in AI
  • Rapidly evolving technology
  • Intense competition
  • New, innovative entrants

2. Porter's Five Forces

This is a framework used to assess the competitive landscape of an industry. By analyzing these factors you can gain a better understanding of the challenges and opportunities facing your business:

  • Threat of new entrants: New project management tools can easily enter the market, increasing competition.
  • Bargaining power of suppliers: Dependence on specific technology providers can give them leverage over your operations.
  • Bargaining power of buyers: Clients have many project management tools to choose from, giving them strong negotiating power.
  • Threat of substitutes: Alternatives like basic task management apps or manual methods can replace traditional project management software.
  • Industry rivalry: The project management industry is highly competitive, with constant pressure to innovate and offer competitive pricing.

3. Perceptual Mapping

Perceptual mapping is a technique used to visualize how customers perceive different brands about specific factors. By plotting your competitors on a perceptual map, you can understand how your product is positioned relative to others and identify opportunities to differentiate yourself.

Tools for SaaS competitive analysis

When conducting a competitor analysis, utilizing the right tools is crucial. By effectively employing SEO and keyword research tools, social media monitoring platforms, and email and communication tracking tools, you can collect valuable data to guide your strategies effectively.

  1. SEO and keyword research tools provide insights into competitor websites’ traffic, search engine rankings, and keyword usage. This information helps you understand their SEO strategies and spot opportunities to enhance your own. Here are some tools that you can use. 
  1. Social media monitoring tools track competitor activity on various platforms, analyze engagement metrics, and provide insights into their brand perception. By leveraging this data, you can refine your social media strategy and respond effectively to market dynamics. 
  1. Email and communication tracking tools monitor and analyze interactions between your competitors and their clients or prospects. These tools provide insights into email open rates, click-through rates, and response times, revealing how effectively competitors engage with their audience. 

Remember, the most effective approach is to combine these tools with qualitative research and a deep understanding of your target market. By leveraging technology and strategic analysis, you can gain a competitive edge and drive growth for your SaaS business.

Upgrade your Strategy with TripleDart

While the tools mentioned above can be valuable assets in competitor analysis, conducting a thorough and effective analysis can be a time-consuming and complex process. In-house marketing teams often face several challenges when tackling competitor analysis themselves:

  • Time constraints: In-house teams often juggle multiple responsibilities alongside competitor analysis. This can limit the time spent on in-depth research and strategic planning.
  • Limited expertise: Individual team members may not possess the broad range of expertise needed to analyze competitor strategies across all channels. A dedicated agency can provide a full-service approach, encompassing SEO, social media, email marketing, and content analysis.
  • Cost considerations: Building the necessary tech stack and acquiring the specialized skills for comprehensive competitor analysis can be expensive for an in-house team. Partnering with an agency can be a cost-effective solution, as you pay for their expertise and access to existing resources.

At TripleDart, we specialize in B2B and SaaS marketing, with a strong focus on fostering significant business growth. We understand the importance of competitor analysis and its role in developing winning marketing strategies.

Our team of experienced professionals has a profound grasp g of the SaaS landscape and the tools needed to conduct a comprehensive competitor analysis. We’ll assist you in delving deeper than surface-level data to uncover essential aspects of your competitors' strategies. Let us handle the time-intensive competitor analysis tasks, allowing your in-house team to focus on core business functions.

TripleDart is your one-stop shop for all your SaaS marketing needs. Contact us today and let our team of experts help you unlock the full potential of your business!

Shiyam Sunder
Shiyam Sunder
Shiyam is a Demand Generation marketer and Growth Advisor with a passion for numbers and scientific methods. As the Founder of TripleDart, he specializes in building scalable demand generation programs for SaaS businesses. With over 9 years of experience in B2B SaaS, Shiyam has a proven track record of helping more than 50 SaaS companies optimize their customer acquisition models, develop demand generation playbooks, and drive growth.

We'd Love to Work with You!

Join 70+ successful B2B SaaS companies on the path to achieving T2D3 with our SaaS marketing services.